Superannuation Decoded

Australian superannuation for ordinary people, in plain English

SMSF vs industry fund: which suits you?

The Brisbane sign with the city skyline at night
The Brisbane sign with the city skyline at night. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC0.
The Brisbane skyline at night from Kangaroo Point
The Brisbane skyline at night from Kangaroo Point. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC0.
A CityCat ferry passing under the Kangaroo Point Bridge, Brisbane
A CityCat ferry passing under the Kangaroo Point Bridge, Brisbane. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC0.

Most Australians are in an industry fund or a retail fund and never think about it. A self-managed super fund (SMSF) is the alternative: you run the fund yourself, choose every investment, and carry the legal responsibility. The choice is mostly about balance size, appetite for paperwork, and what you want to invest in.

In short

An SMSF gives you control — direct property, individual shares, collectables within strict rules — but costs $2,000 to $5,000 a year to run, plus your time. An industry fund costs a fraction of that and needs no work from you. Below about $200,000 in super, an industry fund almost always leaves you better off; above $300,000 to $400,000, an SMSF can start to make sense.

Cost: the decisive difference

An SMSF has fixed costs: the $259 ATO levy, the audit, accounting and administration, typically $2,000 to $5,000 a year for a straightforward fund. Those costs do not shrink with a small balance — $3,000 a year is 3% of $100,000.

An industry fund charges a percentage: a large fund with an indexed option can cost 0.1% to 0.5% a year. On $100,000 that is $100 to $500 — a tenth of the SMSF's cost. The crossover, where the SMSF's fixed costs become cheaper than the fund's percentage fees, is usually around $200,000 to $300,000, depending on the fund.

Control: what an SMSF can do

An SMSF can hold direct residential or commercial property, individual shares, term deposits, and — within strict rules — collectables and personal-use assets. It can borrow under a limited recourse borrowing arrangement, though from 10 August 2026 new LRBAs are restricted to business real property only.

An industry fund offers a menu of investment options — high growth, balanced, conservative, indexed, ethical — but you cannot pick individual assets or buy a property. For most people the menu is enough; for a business owner who wants the fund to own the business premises, only an SMSF works.

Work and responsibility

SMSF trustees are personally liable for compliance. The fund needs a written investment strategy, reviewed regularly; an independent audit every year; an annual return to the ATO; and records kept for years. A compliance failure can cost the fund its complying status — 45% tax on income.

An industry fund does all of that for you. Your only jobs are choosing an investment option, checking your insurance, and keeping your details up to date. If you would not enjoy the paperwork, that is a real cost, not a minor detail.

Insurance and tax

Industry funds include default death and disability insurance, often at group rates that are hard to beat individually. SMSF members must arrange their own insurance, and the fund must consider insurance for its members as part of its investment strategy.

Tax is the same in both: 15% on fund earnings, 0% on retirement-phase earnings, and the same caps and Division 296 rules. An SMSF gives more scope for tax planning — timing capital gains, franking credits, and pension strategies — but only if the trustees know how to use it.

Who should choose which

Choose an industry fund if your balance is under $200,000, you want low cost and no paperwork, and you are happy with diversified options. Choose an SMSF if your balance is above $300,000, you want direct property or specific assets, you run a business, or you genuinely enjoy managing investments — and you accept the legal responsibility.

A middle path exists: some retail and industry funds now offer direct investment options, including ASX shares and ETFs, for a small extra fee. That buys much of the SMSF's control without the compliance burden, and it is worth checking before committing to a fund of your own.

Sources: ATO, Self-managed super funds; ASFA, SMSF costs; ATO, SMSF supervisory levy $259.

General information only. This page explains Australian superannuation in plain English. It is not tax advice or personal financial advice, and it cannot tell you what you owe or what you should do about your own super. Always confirm the current caps, rates, and your own position on ato.gov.au or with a licensed financial adviser before you act. Contact: hello [at] tapetoolhq.com.